EDWARD'S LECTURE NOTES:
More notes at http://tanguay.info/learntracker
C O U R S E 
Chinese Thought: Ancient Wisdom Meets Modern Science
Edward Slingerland, University of British Columbia
https://www.edx.org/course/ubcx/ubcx-china300x-chinese-thought-ancient-3331
C O U R S E   L E C T U R E 
Wu-Wei, Dao, Tien and De
Notes taken on November 14, 2014 by Edward Tanguay
•
wu wei [OO-way]
•
an important concept in Taoism that means "without effort" or "without control" or "effortless action", the way beings in harmony with the Tao behave,
•
in a completely natural, uncontrived way, which is the goal of spiritual practice for the human being
•
the attainment of a purely natural way of behaving, as when the planets revolve around the sun
•
engaging in effortless and spontaneous movement
•
wu wei is often translated as "without action" or "no action"
•
not a very good translation because often people who are in wu wei are actually very active
•
very it is just that their action is effortless and natural
•
people who are in a state of wu wei often emerge having done something amazing not even realizing at the time that they were doing anything
•
like being "in the zone" in sports
•
the sense of "being in the flow" an idea popularized in the 1990s by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi
•
lose the sense of yourself as an agent
•
get absorbed into your activities
•
lose the sense of the passing of time
•
forget that you are doing something in particular
•
however, there are important differences between wu wei and the flow
•
flow is about complexity, challenge, and the need to be constantly ramped up
•
if an activity is too hard we get frustrated
•
if it is too easy we get bored
•
flow is a channel, a sweet spot right between these two extremes
•
most athletics and highly skilled activities fit this description
•
wu-wei captures a broader range of activities
•
what distinguishes wu-wei from other states is being absorbed in something larger than yourself
•
this bigger thing is something that you value
•
something that is normatively positive, something you believe to be morally good
•
you become very effective in the world
•
people who are in wu-wei are in a state of spontaneity
•
but the English word spontaneity has too much of a sense of arbitrariness
•
wu-wei is focused
•
but it is not you that is doing the focussing
•
you are no longer the acting agent
•
you can think of wu-wei as an integration of hot and cold cognition
•
it's body thinking, no conscious thought is necessary
•
wu wei represents being harmonized with a greater whole
•
Dao
•
a path, or road, or way
•
beginning with Confucius is begins to mean the way of the universe, the proper way
•
when you are in a state of wu-wei, you are acting in accordance with the Dao
•
tian
•
heaven, or heaven's will
•
when you are in a state of wu-wei you are in accord with what heaven wants
•
de [pronounced unfortunately "duh" as in "no duh"]
•
means Virtue
•
a better translation is "charismatic power"
•
a power that you emanate when you are in a state of wu-wei
•
attracts people to you
•
as a Confucian ruler, it's what makes people want to follow you without you having to force them to follow you
•
the paradox of getting to wu-wei
•
explained through a game called "mindball"
•
goal is to relax more than the opposite player
•
the more you slow down your brain activity, the more you relax, the better chance you will win
•
the goal is to push the little metal ball to the other side of the table
•
if you get it there, you win
•
the way you push it is through relaxing and thus producing alpha and beta waves, which is what the electrodes pick up, and thus move the ball
•
it's all the extraneous thoughts that you have to get rid of
•
you win mindball by not trying to win
•
a good microcosm of this problem of how you can try not to try
•
it turns out that trying not to try is not very easy
•
we all face something like the mindball tension in our everyday lives
•
choking in sports is a version of the paradox of wu-wei
•
how do you make yourself relaxed when you're not feeling relaxed
•
dating
•
it's hard to relax when you feel like you should be performing, being someone who the other person will be interested in
•
each of the thinkers who think about wu-wei suggest a tension to be wu-wei and get de
•
it is a real paradox so there isn't one solution to it
•
the way ancient philosophers dealt with this tension of trying not to try has bearing on our everyday lives
•
where we want spontaneity but find it elusive